Treatment, Replacement Basis and Contaminant Release in Cementitious Mixtures Containing Mswi Fly Ash and Apc Residues: A Quantitative Review of Accessible Experimental Evidence

Authors

  • Raffaella Pomi Associate Professor, Department of Civil, Building and Environmental Engineering, Sapienza University of Rome, Rome, Italy Author
  • Andrea Turolla Associate Professor, Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Politecnico di Milano, Milan, Italy Author

Keywords:

MSWI Fly Ash, Air-Pollution-Control Residue, Cement Replacement, Compressive Strength, Contaminant Leaching, Comparator Validity, Quantitative Evidence Review

Abstract

Municipal solid waste incineration (MSWI) residues are investigated as cementitious constituents, but treatment benefits can be misinterpreted when fly ash and air-pollution-control (APC) residues, replacement denominators, and leaching conditions are combined. This review asks what source-verified, matched comparisons show about treatment, compressive strength and product contaminant release. A prospective extraction and analysis protocol preceded numerical extraction. Six targeted queries were executed in Crossref and OpenAlex on 7 October 2026, retrieving the first 100 records per query and provider. After deduplication and documented machine-assisted title triage, complete accessible original papers were assessed. Confirmed fly ash, APC residues and unresolved collection streams were separated. Exact printed values were extracted without graph-coordinate digitization; censored results were retained. Within-study ratios were calculated only for interpretable comparisons. Search restrictions and a subsequent focus on cement-containing systems are disclosed. The bounded search yielded 1,200 metadata records and 763 unique candidates. Of 98 reports sought, 28 were retrieved and 11 included; 70 reports remained inaccessible. The dataset contains 55 exact strength means, six source-reported relative strength results and 573 product-leaching entries, including controls and censored entries. In one APC study, incremental milling after washing at 35% replacement increased 28-day strength from 22.3 to 32.4 MPa while Cd, Cr and Zn extract concentrations decreased by 98.0%, 91.4% and 38.3%, respectively. In confirmed fly ash, combined washing and electrodialysis increased late-interval Pb release from 3.4 to 14 mg/m² in acidic-start water, despite reductions in selected other endpoints. Heating previously washed ash produced opposing responses by analyte and extraction method. A UHPC series showed strength retention declining from 94.3% to 60.7% across 6–24% ash by total binder mass; these doses correspond to 7.79–31.17% displacement of reference OPC. No strength study met strict confirmed-fly-ash classification, and no pooled estimate or confidence interval was justified. Treatment cannot be assigned a universal strength or environmental benefit. The strongest joint matched comparison concerned a single APC stream, whereas confirmed-fly-ash evidence was leaching-only. Replacement basis, reference mixture and exposure protocol must remain explicit. The evidence supports study-specific tradeoffs and improved experimental reporting, rather than an optimal replacement percentage or construction-safety claim.

Downloads

Published

2026-03-30

Issue

Section

Articles

How to Cite

Treatment, Replacement Basis and Contaminant Release in Cementitious Mixtures Containing Mswi Fly Ash and Apc Residues: A Quantitative Review of Accessible Experimental Evidence. (2026). International Journal of Engineering Innovation and Computational Science, 1(1), 33-49. https://journovapublishing.com/journals/ijeics/article/view/6

Similar Articles

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.